http://thepoliticalmethodologist.com/2014/12/09/a-decade-of-replications-lessons-from-the-quarterly-journal-of-political-science/

Should we have tighter policies for code submitted?

MH seems to think that I have been too harsh on his/her R code. But given the dismal records of academic replication, even given the same data, strict review of code seems in place.

Thoughts?