Hello There, Guest!  

Reviewers

#27
(2015-Mar-16, 20:15:51)Emil Wrote: I don't know what you mean, "limit".


Bad wording, due to my poor english I guess. I meant : "set the minimum to three".

By the way, now that I think about external reviewers, I think the editors should make the following statement in the rules : If the author wants to recruit an external reviewer, he must "Cc" one of the editors whenever he sends an invitation to review.

I know that there is actually a recommendation that an author should make publicly available the email conversation, but I'm not talking about that. I say that an invitation to review must contain a Cc to the editor. First, because it will increase the probability that a reviewer will accept the invitation, and because the editor will know the kind of persons the author is requesting help. I think the author should also say in the mail that the journal allows the author to recruit an external reviewer, and this is why the author sends the invitation. Because otherwise, the guys may not necessarily trust the appropriateness of the journal's policy.

If the author is an editor, I suppose he can Cc the other editor(s).

Generally, except for data (unless the data has sharing restrictions), I don't like being told by the journals that I'm obliged to do "this" and "that" (e.g., give the address, phone numbers, and other informations) but honestly, a mail Cc is not costly, so there is no reason not to do it.
 Reply
 
Messages In This Thread
Reviewers - by Emil - 2014-Mar-24, 10:51:41
RE: List of reviewers - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Mar-25, 04:03:59
RE: List of reviewers - by Emil - 2014-Mar-25, 16:03:07
RE: Reviewers - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Mar-29, 00:33:16
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2014-Mar-29, 15:26:29
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2014-Mar-30, 19:46:44
RE: Reviewers - by Dalliard - 2014-Jul-14, 20:59:47
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2014-Jul-15, 01:29:23
RE: Reviewers - by Meng Hu - 2014-Jul-16, 00:06:32
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2014-Oct-09, 05:48:32
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2014-Jul-16, 08:43:30
RE: Reviewers - by Meng Hu - 2014-Jul-16, 13:01:27
RE: Reviewers - by Duxide - 2014-Sep-08, 18:06:41
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2014-Sep-08, 21:20:30
RE: Reviewers - by Meng Hu - 2014-Oct-09, 17:13:55
RE: Reviewers - by Meng Hu - 2015-Jan-30, 19:54:43
RE: Reviewers - by Duxide - 2015-Jan-30, 21:05:39
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2015-Jan-30, 20:28:14
RE: Reviewers - by Duxide - 2015-Feb-02, 18:20:20
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2015-Feb-02, 18:39:29
RE: Reviewers - by Duxide - 2015-Feb-02, 20:53:33
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2015-Feb-05, 16:47:57
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2015-Mar-01, 13:02:24
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2015-Mar-16, 18:21:56
RE: Reviewers - by Meng Hu - 2015-Mar-16, 19:33:42
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2015-Mar-16, 20:15:51
RE: Reviewers - by Meng Hu - 2015-Mar-20, 00:56:56
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2015-Oct-28, 23:50:19
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2015-Nov-27, 21:34:34
RE: Reviewers - by Emil - 2015-Nov-27, 21:54:07
RE: Reviewers - by Peter Frost - 2016-Jun-07, 13:33:33
RE: Reviewers - by Gmeisenberg - 2016-Jun-07, 16:05:32
 
Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)