OpenPsych forums
[OQSPS] Immigrant crime in Germany 2012-2015 - Printable Version

+- OpenPsych forums (
+-- Forum: Forums (
+--- Forum: Post-review discussions (
+--- Thread: [OQSPS] Immigrant crime in Germany 2012-2015 (/showthread.php?tid=296)

Pages: 1 2

RE: [OQSPS] Immigrant crime in Germany 2012-2015 - Gmeisenberg - 2017-Feb-11

The paper is interesting and adds usefully to what we know already from the Scandinavian countries. The methods seem to be OK, although there are of course serious limitations of the data. It would be nice if the Statistics Office would report where people were born and where their parents and grandparents were born. But that's something we can do nothing about. Especially interesting is the correction for sex and age for the country-level analysis based on individual-level data. I don't remember having seen that kind of procedure before. I only marked some minor typos and stylistic details in the paper. Otherwise it's ready to go, I would think. I approve.

RE: [OQSPS] Immigrant crime in Germany 2012-2015 - Emil - 2017-Feb-11

We fixed the minor issues pointed out. Mostly grammar and missing/duplicate words (i.e. typical Emil errors).

Not sure what you mean by individual-level data. We had no such data. But we did have those age x sex data from Denmark which allowed for the validation of the new adjustment method.